Which Is Better: Buying A Diesel Or Petrol Used Car?

Written by Danny Collins
Last updated: June 12, 2023

The popularity of diesel cars has waned in recent years due to the environmental impact of their emissions. The alternative, petrol cars, are not without their problems. Petrol cars produce more carbon dioxide than diesel, one of the main greenhouse gases responsible for climate change.

So, which is the better option? If you’re looking to buy a used car, should you go for a diesel or petrol model? This depends on many factors, including your circumstances and driving habits. Let’s look at some of the pros and cons of each option to help you make a decision.

What’s The Difference Between The Diesel And Petrol Cars?

Diesel cars have a higher fuel efficiency than petrol cars, meaning they use less fuel to travel the same distance. This makes the cars cheaper to run in the long term. Diesel cars also emit less carbon dioxide than petrol cars, making them better for the environment. However, diesel cars produce higher nitrogen oxides and particulates, harming human health. Diesel cars also tend to be more expensive to buy than petrol cars.

Petrol cars have a lower fuel efficiency than diesel cars, meaning they use more fuel to travel the same distance. This makes them more expensive to run in the long term. Petrol cars also emit more carbon dioxide than diesel cars, making them worse for the environment. However, petrol cars produce lower nitrogen oxides and particulates, harming human health. Petrol cars also tend to be cheaper to buy than diesel cars.

So, which is the better option? If you’re looking to buy used automobiles, should you go for a diesel or petrol model? This depends on many factors, including your circumstances and driving habits. Let’s look at some of the pros and cons of each option to help you make a decision.

What Are The Pros And Cons Of Purchasing Diesel Cars?

Diesel cars have many advantages. They’re cheaper to run than petrol cars, emit less carbon dioxide, and have a higher fuel efficiency. Diesel cars are generally more reliable and have a longer lifespan than petrol cars. This makes the diesel car’s value hold up better over time, meaning you’re less likely to lose money if you sell it.

However, diesel cars also have some disadvantages. They produce higher nitrogen oxides and particulates, harming human health. Diesel cars also tend to be more expensive to buy than petrol cars. This is because diesel engines are more complex than petrol engines and require more expensive parts and maintenance.

What Are The Pros And Cons Of Petrol Cars?

Petrol cars have many advantages. They’re cheaper than diesel cars, emit less carbon dioxide, and produce lower nitrogen oxides and particulates. The tax on petrol cars is also lower than on diesel cars. Petrol cars have a higher resale value than diesel cars, meaning you’re more likely to make money if you decide to sell them.

However, petrol cars also have some disadvantages. They’re more expensive to run than diesel cars, emit more carbon dioxide, and have lower fuel efficiency. This is because petrol engines are less complex than diesel engines and require less expensive parts and maintenance.

So, Which Is The Better Option?

It depends on many factors, including your circumstances and driving habits. A diesel car may be your better option if you prefer simplicity and lower running costs. A petrol car may be the better option if you’re looking for a cheaper upfront investment and don’t mind higher running costs. Ultimately, the decision is yours. Whichever option you choose, make sure to do your research to ensure you get the best deal.

What To Prepare Before You Buy A Used Car

If you’re looking to buy a used car, you should do a few things before making your purchase. First, research the types of cars available and decide which is right for you. Second, get a vehicle history report to ensure your interested car is in good condition.

This will tell you if the automobile has been in any accidents, has any outstanding finance, or has any other problems that could affect your decision to buy it. 

Finally, take the automobile for a test drive to make sure it’s the right fit for you. Once you’ve done all this, you’ll be ready to buy your used car confidently!

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What factors should I consider when deciding between a diesel or petrol used car?

When deciding between a diesel or petrol used car, there are several factors to consider. These include your driving habits, mileage, maintenance costs, environmental impact, and fuel economy. Understanding these factors will help you make an informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences.

 

Is a diesel used car more fuel-efficient than a petrol used car?

Diesel engines traditionally offer better fuel economy than petrol engines due to their higher energy density. However, the difference in fuel efficiency between diesel and petrol engines has diminished in recent years due to advancements in petrol engine technology. It is essential to compare the specific models you are considering to determine their fuel efficiency ratings.

 

Which type of engine has a longer lifespan: diesel or petrol?

The lifespan of an engine depends on various factors, including design, build quality, maintenance practices, driving habits, and environmental conditions. Historically, diesel engines have been known for their durability and longer lifespan compared to petrol engines. Diesel engines are typically built with stronger internal components to handle higher compression ratios and the rigours of diesel combustion, which often translates into a longer lifespan.

However, with advancements in petrol engine technology, the gap in terms of engine lifespan has narrowed. Modern petrol engines now incorporate lightweight materials, improved lubrication systems, and advanced engineering techniques, allowing them to offer increased reliability and durability. With regular maintenance and proper care, modern petrol engines can also provide a long and trouble-free service life.

 

How does the cost of diesel fuel compare to petrol?

The cost of diesel fuel compared to petrol can vary depending on regional market dynamics, taxes, and government policies. Historically, diesel fuel tended to be cheaper than petrol due to differences in taxation and refining costs. Diesel engines’ higher fuel efficiency made them a popular choice for long-distance drivers and commercial vehicles, as the cost savings from fuel consumption often outweighed the higher purchase price of diesel cars.

 

Are diesel-used cars more expensive to maintain than petrol-used cars?

Diesel used cars tend to have higher maintenance costs compared to their petrol counterparts. Diesel engines have more complex systems and components, such as turbochargers and particulate filters, which may require additional maintenance and potentially costly repairs. Additionally, diesel engines often require specific maintenance procedures and specialised fluids. It’s important to factor in these potential expenses when considering a diesel-used car.

 

Are there any environmental differences between diesel and petrol engines?

When comparing the environmental impact of diesel and petrol engines, several factors come into play. Historically, diesel engines were known for their higher emissions of particulate matter (PM) and nitrogen oxides (NOx) compared to petrol engines. However, advancements in diesel engine technology have led to significant improvements in reducing these harmful pollutants.

Modern diesel cars are equipped with advanced emission control systems, such as Diesel Particulate Filters (DPF) and Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR), which effectively reduce particulate emissions and NOx levels. As a result, the environmental differences between diesel and petrol engines have become less pronounced.

 

Are diesel engines noisier than petrol engines?

Historically, diesel engines were often associated with higher noise levels compared to petrol engines. This was primarily due to the combustion process and the mechanical characteristics of diesel engines, which typically involve higher compression ratios and a different type of ignition.

However, advancements in diesel engine technology have significantly reduced noise levels in modern diesel cars. Manufacturers have implemented various measures to mitigate noise, including improved engine design, better sound insulation, and the use of advanced fuel injection systems. As a result, the noise difference between diesel and petrol engines has become less pronounced.

 

Which type of used car is better for long-distance driving?

Diesel used cars are often considered more suitable for long-distance driving due to their better fuel economy and torque characteristics. Diesel engines generate more low-end torque, which provides better-pulling power and makes them well-suited for highway driving and towing heavy loads. However, petrol used cars with efficient engines can also be suitable for long-distance driving, especially if you prefer a quieter and smoother ride.

 

Are diesel-used cars more suitable for towing purposes?

Diesel used cars are often preferred for towing purposes due to their higher torque output. Torque is the twisting force produced by the engine, and diesel engines typically offer more low-end torque, providing better-pulling power. This makes diesel used cars better suited for towing heavy trailers, caravans, or boats. However, there are petrol-used cars with powerful engines that can also be suitable for towing, depending on the weight and requirements of the towing task.

 

What are the potential drawbacks of buying a diesel-used car?

While diesel-used cars have their advantages, there are some potential drawbacks to consider. These include higher initial purchase costs, higher maintenance and repair costs, stricter emissions regulations in certain areas, and potential difficulties finding diesel fuel stations in some regions. Additionally, some diesel engines may have a reputation for being noisier and emitting more vibrations compared to petrol engines. It’s important to weigh these factors against the benefits when deciding on a diesel-used car.

 

Are there any financial incentives for buying a diesel or petrol used car?

Financial incentives for buying a diesel or petrol used car vary depending on the country and region. In some areas, diesel vehicles may face higher taxes or restricted access to certain urban zones due to environmental concerns. On the other hand, some regions offer incentives for purchasing low-emission vehicles, including petrol or diesel hybrids, electric cars, or vehicles meeting specific emissions standards. It’s recommended to research local regulations and incentives applicable to your location.

 

Can I convert a diesel-used car into a petrol-used car or vice versa?

Converting a diesel used car into a petrol used car or vice versa is technically possible but highly impractical and often not cost-effective. The conversion process involves replacing the engine, modifying the fuel system, and making various other adjustments to the vehicle. These conversions are complex and require specialised knowledge and equipment. It’s generally more sensible to choose a used car with the desired engine type from the beginning rather than attempting a conversion.

 

Are there any resale value differences between diesel and petrol cars?

The resale value of a car depends on various factors, including market trends, supply and demand dynamics, the perceived reliability and desirability of the model, and regional factors. Historically, diesel cars had better resale value compared to petrol cars due to their higher fuel efficiency and lower fuel costs, which made them attractive to buyers, particularly those who covered long distances.

However, changing market dynamics and increasing concerns about emissions have affected the resale value of diesel cars in some regions. As stricter emission regulations and environmental awareness come into play, the demand for diesel cars may decline, potentially impacting their resale value.

 

Are there differences in insurance costs between diesel and petrol cars?

Insurance costs for vehicles are determined by several factors, including the driver’s age and experience, driving record, location, vehicle make and model, and engine type. While diesel cars may have higher repair costs due to specialised components, insurance premiums depend on multiple variables and are not solely determined by the type of engine.

Insurance companies assess risk based on factors such as the likelihood of accidents, repair costs, and the availability and cost of spare parts for a particular vehicle. While diesel cars may have higher repair costs, other factors, such as the specific make and model of the vehicle, its safety features, and the driver’s profile, also influence insurance premiums.

Related posts

How Many Miles Is Too Much For a Used Car?

Leasing Or Buying A Used Car: What’s Right For You?

What Is The Best Age To Buy a Used Car?